[Letters Logo]

 

The comments made on these pages are the views of the person writing them and may not be the same as those of the Webmaster. This website is not responsible for any thing expressed on these Letter pages, and care should be taken before trying out any of these ideas.

Skimmers - South African style

The type of system generally used in the UK looks like this:
This necessitates building a skimmer box into the wall during construction, installing an extra, necessarily powerful pump, adding a lot of extra piping runs and valvework and finally, a timer is usually recommended. This all adds up to a lot of extra cost and complexity plus ongoing running costs. (It is, however, a tried and tested system that works well).

I live in a community where swimming pools are commonplace. They all have these skimmer boxes built into the wall but none of them are ever used as a skimming device.
When I was a child I can remember these wall mounted skimmer boxes had a hinged flap with a float on top. Water was pumped from inside the skimmer box (or weir as we call them) and the hinged flap ensured that only the very surface of the water was "skimmed" off.
In the last 30 years I have not seen a swimming pool working like this (and the way you are using them in koi ponds).
What happened was that somebody invented the automated pool cleaner ("KreepyKraully" or "Barracuda" amongst others) and the hose from these devices plugged into the weir. There was now no longer any surface water flow through the weir so we stopped calling them skimmer boxes.
Here is what the setup usually looks like.
These automated pool cleaners were great for cleaning the bottom of a swimming pool but floating debris needed a new solution as the skimmer box has had it's function usurped.

What has been developed are skimming devices that utilise some of the energy of the returning water jet coming back into the pool from a wall outlet. (Just like some of the energy of returning water has been utilised in koi ponds to entrain air in the familiar venturi returns.)
Skimming devices employing a similar venturi principle are everyday here and are very effective at skimming surface debris and depositing it into a mesh bag.
This is a typical one. The round white body has an inner which can slide up and down and ends in the doughnut shaped white float. Only the surface water is pulled over this float.
The blue bag is emptied periodically. It is surprising how rapidly it fills with fine floating debris as well as the obvious leaves etc.
In the background you can see the automated pool cleaner on the end of its hose on the pool bottom.
Here is the exact same device in a koi pond where it is just as effective.
It was just attached to a near-surface return pipe that did not yet have a use.
It has recently been disturbed so the some of the algae has come off leaving the obvious white very visible. It would be much more satisfactory if it was also made in black.
In this picture you get a better idea of just how effectively it removes surface water.
The fine mesh bag is too fine and readily clogs. It is frequently left off and the fine floating debris is "drowned" giving the pond that oily smooth look. However, when leaves are falling the bag is necessary. A bag of coarser black mesh would be preferable and easily made. 20% shade cloth works well.

The cost of this device here was less than equiv of £20 UK. Something to think about.....
I am not proposing that this device is superior to the one illustrated at the top of the page, that remains the gold standard. It is simpler and less expensive to install and run and may offer a solution as a later add-on.

Parting thought:
The surface of your pond is the biggest air/water interface for gas exchange that your pond has.
It is in a very real sense the pond's "lung".
If the skimmer is working well it ensures that this surface layer of water is continuously replaced, bring up new water for gas exchange. It has been suggested that this is far more important for gas exchange than the aerating venturi return.
Peter Winters - South Africa

Click on any image for a larger image


Home - Pond descriptions - Pond heating - Pond construction - Koi health - Projects - Products - Photos from Japan - South Wales section - Letters - Links - Guest-book - Statistics - New - Forum
Website Copyright © 1999-2009 Koi Cymru